If you like my work, buy me a virtual cup of coffee at Ko-Fi.

After the controversial Star Trek Strange New Worlds musical episode and whatever latest mess actor Robert Beltran (who played Chakotay on “Star Trek: Voyager”) stepped in, the question once again comes up, “What is a true Star Trek fan?” We could just rephrase it as “What is real Star Trek?”

I’ll say right now that there’s no one right answer. However, fandom being what it is, every perspective in Star Trek fandom believes it has the one, only, and right answer to those questions.

For instance from Quora:

The five series; TOS, TNG, DS9. Voyager, Enterprise.. plus the first 10 movies.. are what I consider canon, because they are aligned with Gene Roddenberry’s vision of what Star Trek is supposed to be, which is the exploration and development of humanity and its borders, and the conflict that comes with it.

All those that violate this established canon, is not what I’d call “real Star Trek”.. and that includes all the Abrams films and ST Discovery. Now I’m not saying that they are not fine pieces or work.. I am just saying that it is not really Star Trek.

Then from reddit:

Continue reading →