Moshe Katz was in New York visiting his Tante and Feter, and they made the San Francisco Private Detective play tourist, including a visit to the Met’s Diamond Jubilee. Then things got ridiculous. He’d heard of Marian Anderson, but who the hell were Judy Collins, Yo-Yo Ma, and Itzhak Perlman?
“Alright, Mr. Watson, I’m going to give you a hand. The local cops don’t know how to handle this sort of thing, but my cases are more unusual.”
“We’d appreciate anything you can do. If word ever got out…”
“Relax. I’ll find out who here has a broken time machine.
I wrote this for the Rochelle Wisoff-Fields photo writing challenge. The idea is to use the image above as the inspiration for crafting a piece of flash fiction no more than 100 words long. My word count is 100.
I became dismayed when I realized that the photo was of a recognizable place, but I didn’t recognize it. Then Google image search came to the rescue. It’s the Metropolitan Museum of Art, otherwise known at the Met.
According to Wikipedia:
The museum celebrated its 75th anniversary (which it termed Diamond Jubilee) with a variety of events in 1946, culminating in the anniversary of the opening of its first exhibition on February 22, 1947.
What is coincidence. I created a San Francisco private detective named Moshe Katz who operates in 1947. He’s featured in the stories Death Visits Mexico and Son of Kristallnacht. So I decided to create a New York mystery for him to solve. Normally, his cases are rather mundane, but for this tale, I decided to change his history a bit.
Again, according to Wikipedia:
In 1954, to celebrate the opening of its Grace Rainey Rogers concert hall, the museum inaugurated a series of concerts, adding art lectures in 1956. This “Concerts & Lectures program” grew over the years into 200 events each season. The program presented such performers as Marian Anderson, Cecilia Bartoli, Judy Collins, Marilyn Horne, Burl Ives, Juilliard String Quartet, Yo-Yo Ma, Itzhak Perlman, Artur Rubinstein, András Schiff, Nina Simone, Joan Sutherland and André Watts, as well as lectures on art history, music, dance, theater and social history.
I didn’t read the paragraph carefully and was wondering how all of those performers could have been at the Met at the same time. Then I read more carefully, but the damage was done. What if there were a time machine accident and they really did appear at the Met simultaneously, and specifically on February 22, 1947?
Oh, Thomas J. Watson was the Met’s Vice President in 1947 and Tante and Feter are Aunt and Uncle in Yiddish.
You can read about the Met’s history to find out more. To read other stories based on the prompt, visit InLinkz.com.
Dear James,
Who else do you call to repair a broken time machine? But not knowing Itzhak Perlman is unthinkable. 😉
Shalom,
Rochelle
LikeLiked by 1 person
Perlman was 18 months old when this story took place, so I think we can forgive Moshe. Thanks, Rochelle.
LikeLike
But Rochelle, Moshe is a detective, not a technician; how can he be expected to repair a broken time machine? We may certainly expect of him the marvel of deducing the nature of the problem, but tracking down the malfunctioning machine and someone capable of repairing it might be just a bit beyond his admittedly-prodigious capabilities, don’t you think? It could, nonetheless, offer very interesting possibilities for a longer story — for example, perhaps he might locate some all-but-invisible portal from which each of these anachronisms emerged (perhaps even deducing that it moved around per some pattern that he must identify and map to predict its next location), enter it to another time where the malfunctioning machine is operating, locate its designer (who might be injured and in need of help), and work together to resolve the problem and return each anachronistic visitor to his or her own time (including himself).
Worse, the assumption of a broken-but-repairable time machine might be over-optimistic. What if the phenomenon is currently a random natural anomaly that strikes virtually unpredictably like lightning, even it were initially triggered by some future experiment that ranged out-of-control or beyond its design parameters? Of course, one must consider why it would be striking musicians particularly and dropping them into the Met in 1947 — if, in fact, that is all it is doing — hence it is not entirely random. Whether that characteristic could be manipulated with the help of the machine that started the phenomenon, in order to resolve the problem, is a process that could be hard to imagine and even harder to design (or for a writer to describe).
It might even require yet another generation or two of further research to perfect the technology of controlled time travel before it would become possible to open portals into 1947 at the Met in order to seize the anachronistic visitors/victims at the moment of their arrival and return each one to their own time at the moment after they had been extracted from it, so that their memory of the event would be minimized and seem nothing more than an unexpected daydream or momentary hallucination. An even better solution might be to open a portal prior to the experiment-gone-wrong, in order to send an agent who could prevent that experiment and its failure along with its consequences.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Actually, almost two years ago, I wrote The Woman Who Fell Into Time which was based on an accident at the CERN accellerator producing invisible time portals that randomly shift people from one time to another, so I suppose something like this could be the result.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s interesting. I didn’t remember having read that story when I wrote my second paragraph above about precisely that sort of accident. I was just pursuing logical possibilities.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve been puzzling over how a set of anomalous time bubbles from the CERN experiment could have selected specifically a few musicians and the event at the Met. I have one idea, albeit a little far-fetched: you mentioned a vibration at the collider when the experiment began to generate its time bubbles. Suppose, then, that this vibration set a condition that keyed each bubble to resonate with an identical vibration or musical tone wherever it might appear across the timescape. Each of the anachronistic performers had to have been extracted from his or her time already with their instrument in hand and dressed for a performance, in order to fit the Met venue, Suppose further that a performer at the Met had also struck such a tone, with all its signature harmonics, providing a focal point to establish a cascade effect whereby the first of the extracted performers was brought to 1947 in the midst of their performance, which they continued. Then, as they struck the same tone in 1947, the next performer’s bubble resonated as they also played that tone in their own time, bringing them to the 1947 performance as the subsequent performer. Again, as they played (or sang, in the case of Collins) that tone, the process repeated. In this story, it appears that only three bubbles operated to transfer performers from their own performance times back to the 1947 event at the Met. Now, in your CERN story, the woman physicist returned to her original time automatically, as if the bubble had only a finite duration. Perhaps we might leverage that notion to return our anachronistic performers also to their own times, as soon as the musical vibrations of their individual performances ceased to echo from the walls of the Met.
I’m not sure how we might fit Moshe’s detective work into such a scenario, since the problem would be self-correcting and thus leave few traces to indicate what had occurred, unless somehow we sweep Moshe himself into such a bubble’s field to bring him to their source at CERN. Then, of course, we would have the problem of getting him back to 1947, unless there were yet another lingering bubble with which he might somehow resonate and be carried back to the Met, then escape the bubble’s field in order to remain there.
Granted, it’s a little far-fetched to link the notion of quantum resonance with musical resonance, but such mechanisms are not foreign to scifi.
LikeLiked by 2 people
The ending made it all clear! Loved this story!
Susan A Eames at
Travel, Fiction and Photos
LikeLike
Glad to hear it, Susan. Thanks.
LikeLike
You just go back in time to when it wasn’t broken and make sure that you leave a note for yourself? Good one.
LikeLike
Thanks. Of course, if it’s broken, the trip you suggest may be rather difficult. 😉
LikeLiked by 1 person
A great tale with interesting footnotes. You’ve done it again James!
Click to read my FriFic tale
LikeLike
Thanks, Keith. I tried to work the date into the story, but I only had 100 words to spare.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like that this story grew out of a mis-reading. Provided a great premise 🙂
LikeLike
It happens more often than you’d think, Iain. The consequences of an aging brain.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What an original take on the prompt! Nice work, James!
LikeLike
Thanks, Peggy. The Met has such a rich history, I decided to mash some of it together.
LikeLike
A great tale. Thanks for the prompt pic info.
LikeLike
Thank you and you’re welcome, Yarnspinnerr.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Interesting story!
You Make Me Feel Alive- Anita
LikeLike
Thanks, Anita.
LikeLike
Ending was awesome! Time travel is my favourite topic in fiction.
LikeLike
Mine too. Thanks.
LikeLike
enjoyed the comments here and the fiction – quite a dilemma to have a broken machine
LikeLike
Indeed. Obviously, the time traveler doesn’t want to be discovered but the broken machine is causing havoc. Can it be repaired before intrepid detective Moshe Katz finds him or her out?
LikeLiked by 1 person
hmmmmm
left us hanging
LikeLike
He or she did indeed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
🙂
LikeLike
What a funny story about how you got the idea for this, I love the bouncing thought process. And yes, it’s always seemed to me that once you introduce time machines into a world, pretty soon after you have to deal with time machine mistakes!
LikeLike
Exactly. There’s no fun in a time travel story without accidents, Joy. Thanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ha! Thanks for the explanation. What a fun piece you’ve written.
LikeLike
Thanks for the explanation, I was lost but I like the idea of a time machine repairman. That’s a great story idea.
LikeLike
Thanks. Moshe is a private detective, not a repairman. He needs to find out who has the time machine in order to discover if it can be fixed by the owner. ProclaimLiberty’s response to Rochelle is a very detailed description of the relationships.
LikeLike
I can just imagine a world/job in which broken time machines are a regular hazard.
LikeLike
It would be pretty chaotic, Alice.
LikeLike
A broken time machine would definitely pose a serious problem.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Well, I’ve heard of Judy Collins! Don’t you just hate it when your time machine breaks down at an awkward moment?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, but in 1947 Judy wasn’t quite eight years old yet, Itzhak was only about eighteen months old, and Yo yo wouldn’t be born for yet another eight-and-a-half years. None of them was quite ready to appear at the Met — which is probably a good thing, since an encounter with their adult selves might have been catastrophic. I do think, though, that Moshe was a little too quick to jump to the conclusion that someone present at the event was in possession of a broken time machine. The evidence of anachronistic visitors indicated some time anomaly, of course. But there was not yet any evidence of a machine on the premises or even located within that time period, nor that the operator of such a machine was even present, rather than having projected the visitors to that time from another time. Nor could he have ruled out the possibility of a physicist’s experiment in another time having gone awry, as suggested in the story that James linked above about “The Woman Who Fell Into Time”. But Moshe’s comment was justifiable as an off-the-cuff response to Mr. Watson’s anxiety. I’m sure his actual investigation would be more circumspect and comprehensive.
LikeLiked by 2 people
You do such a lot with 100 words and your footnotes. Always a journey when visiting your site.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Very clever, and I like how your research on the photo inspired your story! Thanks for providing the insight!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Lovely retro story, and thanks for the history, as well. Good one.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The fickleness of machinery… definitely a problem if it is a time machine!! Enjoyed.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Not having heard Itzhak Perlman… me thinks that Moshe needs to learn how to Google.
LikeLike
It would be rather difficult for Moshe to learn to Google in 1947.
LikeLike
That much is true.
LikeLike
Very original. Loved it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your explanation helped the tale a lot!
Quite the research background!
LikeLike
Thanks. I probably could have worked all that in if I wanted to write a longer tale.
LikeLike
Wonderfully imaginative story and equally great comments from your friends. Love it all. Time travel is one of my favorite subjects. Just wish I was inventive enough to write that way myself.
LikeLike
Give it a whirl. You know what they say about practice.
LikeLike
The comments are a story by themselves 🙂 Powerful imagination and very insightful comments.
https://trailbrooklane.blogspot.com/2018/06/the-statue.html
LikeLike
Thank you, Jaya.
LikeLike
I hope he’s got a good set of tools to fix that time machine – he may well need them. Nicely done James
LikeLiked by 1 person
James,
the comments from the others is priceless. You’ve written a story
that’s created quite a bit of dialog. An interesting twist from the other stories I’ve read.
Well done …
Isadora 😎
LikeLike
Thanks, Isadora.
LikeLiked by 1 person